Listen champ, I completely agree with you that metal is more durable than plastic, and pivot 15 are better than attack 14 in that aspect for product lifespan. I also agree that the pivot 15 may have a better release “feel” due to the elasticity and tendency to keep you in the binding
but setting aside durability/release and talking purely
performance (how the binding interacts with ski and boot), the attack 14 is going to be the exact same as pivot 15 if you’re within the din range. They both have almost the exact same stand height (17mm) and ramp delta angle (1-2mm), so power transmission from boot to ski to snow is going to be almost identical. They are both also gonna release at the same value.
let’s put it another way. If you’re sending huge tricks on 50 feet jumps or backcountry cliffs, I’d be just as comfortable on an attack 14 as a pivot 15, because they’re gonna perform the same.
I still disagree with you in that I still believe the weight difference between the two is significant enough that it would lessen the swing weight, but I don’t really have any data or material I can read to justify it other than my experience in preferring lighter skis and bindings after having tried both bindings and freestyle skis of different weights/construction, I lean towards the lighter ones because I don’t need heavy skis to charge through crud or heavy snow since I primarily ski in the park
PartyBullshiitNo matter how many times you keep spouting this nonsense it doesn’t make it any more true. In no world are attack 11/13/14 better than pivot 15’s. Period. The 12/14 pivots, they’re more on par with attacks with both being plastic. More durable means a better binding there champ, which again proves the point that they are better. Athletes have sponsors. They use what their sponsors tell them to use within the range. no one said attacks can’t be trusted. They are just of a Lower level in both performance and quality of pivot 15’s.
swing weight of bindings is a complete myth. Your bindings aren’t mounted at the tips and tails which is what would change your swing weight. Bindings being mounted directly under foot and in most cases near centered on skis has nothing to do with swing weight. The skis weight and tip and tail size will change the swing weight before a binding would ever change that. I see far more riders on pivots in free ride championships than attacks. It’s not even close.
I’m glad attacks work for YOU but that doesn’t change the fact more people who are at the pinnacle of skiing are on pivot 15/18’s. People who are skiing no fall zones and literally risking their lives aren’t choosing plastic attacks. They’re on pivots.