$500 - $750 is actually really reasonable it just wouldn't seem like it if you are in the outside looking in. When I lived in Aspen/Snowmass proper I never paid more than $900 a month and that was for a big room with a walk in closet and one room mate in Club Commons Building 1. I don't mean 10 years ago either I lived in Aspen/Snowmass from 2019-2022. There's even a 1 bedroom unit available on APCHA right now for $972 in Asspen.
What you've got to be looking at is APCHA ran apartment complex's and applying for them instead of looking at a normal apartment site like you would in a more normal place. Then if you really cant find anything on APCHA you use employee housing. Generally if you are using employee housing its worth it to work for Aspen Skiing Company as they've got the nicest and most employee housing of any company in the valley.
Now of days I would avoid Club Commons (Snowmass) unless you are getting in Building 1 as the other ones seem to be filled with drug addicts and loud ass neighbors. But if that's your thing then Club Commons is your place.
My favorite short term apartment complex in Aspen is Burlingame, you pay $650 a month and live across the street from Buttermilk. It tends to fill up with music students, however it is an APCHA complex and will rent to anyone under who makes under ~$55,000 per year. Its Clean, often quite and only does two bedroom units so you don't have to deal with 3 other people.
A lot of the good stuff in Aspen proper has wait lists longer than you can imagine, so a lot of the time the only open spots are for dorm room style apartments like Holiday house and most of Snow Eagle.
If you do end up with Aspen Skiing Company the options they have down valley are much nicer than anything they have in town. Even Tiny Town felt more like a home than Club Commons Building 4 ever did and its just a newly renovated trailer park.
Relevant links below. Good luck.
[URL]https://www.apcha.org/[/URL]
https://www.apcha.org/CivicAlerts.aspx?AID=2059
https://aschousing.managebuilding.com/Resident/public/custom/22
[URL]https://aschousing.managebuilding.com/Resident/public/custom/2[/URL]1