Member of the Month

hi_vis360
November, 2024

Online

Welcome to the Newschoolers forums! You may read the forums as a guest, however you must be a registered member to post. Register to become a member today!

Matej actually won big air?

profile picture
GrandThings
Posts: 3166 - Karma: 31,947
Anybody else see the post in his story? Scored two 48s on different tricks, resulting in a total of 96, that would have beat AHall - but they were incorrectly logged as the same nose butter 19 and therefore didn't count.

Am I misunderstanding this? Feel like there already would have been a thread on this because it might be the wackest thing I've seen come out of Xgames
Jan 27 2022 4:40PM
52 1
profile picture
theabortionator
Posts: 51744 - Karma: 163,523
What tricks were they? I know they were saying they counted a roght sode 10 and 12 as the same because it's adding a 180 to the same rotation.

I wasn't paying that close attention though.
Jan 27 2022 4:43PM
6 0
profile picture
little1337
Posts: 8261 - Karma: 48,269
Bring me back to the good old days of Simon's dub front winning gold :)





I'm kidding btw, who's got the pitchforks?
Jan 27 2022 4:50PM
51 0
profile picture
KCoCM
Posts: 963 - Karma: 8,787
idk why they removed the left and right spin tequirement, it’s the easiest way to just flat out say whether or not the trick is different
Jan 27 2022 4:51PM
16 0
profile picture
GrandThings
Posts: 3166 - Karma: 31,947
theabortionatorWhat tricks were they? I know they were saying they counted a roght sode 10 and 12 as the same because it's adding a 180 to the same rotation.

I wasn't paying that close attention though.


One was a trip 19 and one was a quad. I guess maybe that makes sense, but those feel like pretty damn different tricks to me.
Jan 27 2022 4:54PM
19 2
profile picture
Andi_G
Posts: 3083 - Karma: 15,099
GrandThingsOne was a trip 19 and one was a quad. I guess maybe that makes sense, but those feel like pretty damn different tricks to me.


One was switch and one was a nosebutter right? Along with the differing number of corks. Some bs for sure
Jan 27 2022 5:00PM
11 0
profile picture
GrandThings
Posts: 3166 - Karma: 31,947
AndrewGravesSVOne was switch and one was a nosebutter right? Along with the differing number of corks. Some bs for sure


Wow yep didn't even realize that - the quad was switch
Jan 27 2022 5:02PM
12 1
profile picture
KCoCM
Posts: 963 - Karma: 8,787
regardless of spin direction if one trick is switch and one is forward they’re definitely different tricks imo
GrandThingsWow yep didn't even realize that - the quad was switch
Jan 27 2022 5:05PM
23 0
profile picture
TheDriftingDad
Posts: 151 - Karma: 922
Last time I checked its a lot harder to do a quad than a triple
Jan 27 2022 5:12PM
14 2
profile picture
mrk127
Posts: 1804 - Karma: 16,331
https://www.instagram.com/p/CZPeVxFtthR/


lol his caption. Man is not stoked

Edits: Why tf does embed never work properly
**This post was edited on Jan 27th 2022 at 5:13:22pm

**This post was edited on Jan 27th 2022 at 5:13:57pm

**This post was edited on Jan 27th 2022 at 5:14:21pm

**This post was edited on Jan 27th 2022 at 5:15:03pm

**This post was edited on Jan 27th 2022 at 5:15:42pm
Jan 27 2022 5:13PM
15 0
profile picture
SSteezle
Posts: 9300 - Karma: 7,700
I was wondering how his second trick didn't score better than a 36. So whack. Everyone slayed it but Matej deserved the win and apparently did win. I hope they get him his medal
Jan 27 2022 5:59PM
13 0
profile picture
theabortionator
Posts: 51744 - Karma: 163,523
little1337Bring me back to the good old days of Simon's dub front winning gold :)





I'm kidding btw, who's got the pitchforks?


That was such a painful moment. Thank jebus they got rid of fan voting.
Jan 27 2022 6:04PM
7 0
profile picture
BLandz
Posts: 1678 - Karma: 27,567
If AHall was a beauty he would give the gold to Matej but at the same time I don't blame him for not doing it considering the fact that Matej will probably go on the craziest win streak of all time after this
Jan 27 2022 6:17PM
17 2
profile picture
SSteezle
Posts: 9300 - Karma: 7,700
The judges at Xgames are terrible. It's not fair to the athletes who podium'd, or to Matej. Judges clearly don't even know the tricks the skiers are throwing anymore.
Jan 27 2022 6:44PM
22 0
profile picture
asparagus
Posts: 2489 - Karma: 28,369
theabortionatorWhat tricks were they? I know they were saying they counted a roght sode 10 and 12 as the same because it's adding a 180 to the same rotation.

I wasn't paying that close attention though.


GrandThingsOne was a trip 19 and one was a quad. I guess maybe that makes sense, but those feel like pretty damn different tricks to me.


AndrewGravesSVOne was switch and one was a nosebutter right? Along with the differing number of corks. Some bs for sure


GrandThingsWow yep didn't even realize that - the quad was switch


KCoCMregardless of spin direction if one trick is switch and one is forward they’re definitely different tricks imo


TheDriftingDadLast time I checked its a lot harder to do a quad than a triple


SSteezleI was wondering how his second trick didn't score better than a 36. So whack. Everyone slayed it but Matej deserved the win and apparently did win. I hope they get him his medal


What??? The 48s were for his nosebutter triple 19 safety and nosebutter double 19 japan. The judges plugged in “nosebutter 19” and it counted as the same trick. I think it’s wrong, but that’s what happened. Also the judges probably counted the quad as a triple because the third flip was more of a spin. That’s why the quad only scored high 30s.
Jan 27 2022 6:50PM
17 0
profile picture
asparagus
Posts: 2489 - Karma: 28,369
KCoCMidk why they removed the left and right spin tequirement, it’s the easiest way to just flat out say whether or not the trick is different

Henrik flat-out asked them to change it, the reason:

891779
Jan 27 2022 6:54PM
16 0
profile picture
yungsteeze
Posts: 673 - Karma: 1,969
asparagusWhat??? The 48s were for his nosebutter triple 19 safety and nosebutter double 19 japan. The judges plugged in “nosebutter 19” and it counted as the same trick. I think it’s wrong, but that’s what happened. Also the judges probably counted the quad as a triple because the third flip was more of a spin. That’s why the quad only scored high 30s.


indeed. I was wondering if the judges' reasoning was that he took of forward and spun left both times but i know they don't have that requirement anymore.. i think either way a dub 19 bUiCK and sw dub 21 BuICk are more similar than a dub and a triple with different grabs. future spin gotta win i suppose
Jan 27 2022 7:01PM
2 0
profile picture
Chrischi69
Posts: 652 - Karma: 5,062
I love a hall but matej got absolutely robbed
Jan 27 2022 7:19PM
16 0
profile picture
theabortionator
Posts: 51744 - Karma: 163,523
Honestly the bigger the spins get and the more everyone has them it's going to get harder to judge. Both how to rank 1 against another, and then the nuances of the trick on top of that.
Jan 27 2022 7:33PM
3 0
profile picture
SkierPT
Posts: 2199 - Karma: 4,830
Matej is about to win the next 5+ years.
Hopefully the X-games sale will bring a better future for the event.
Jan 27 2022 11:59PM
7 1
profile picture
snomaster
Posts: 3346 - Karma: 5,771
We figured this out in the official games thread and the NS article on the event notes this controversy in the opening lines.
According the the rules stated during the broadcast, Matej clearly should have won.
but Alex went to the future and stole that shit.
Jan 28 2022 12:18AM
14 0
profile picture
skierman
Posts: 8371 - Karma: 7,590
Member when future spins were a joke because everyone thought they were impossible?
Jan 28 2022 8:45AM
9 1
profile picture
abcdefu
Posts: 182 - Karma: 811
KCoCMidk why they removed the left and right spin tequirement, it’s the easiest way to just flat out say whether or not the trick is different


I think mandating right and left turns definitely leaves no room for discrepancy in differentiating tricks- but idk, pretty obvious to me both Matej's tricks were notably different so I think the judges fucked up.

Also I think removing it does allow for competitors to really work on throwing their craziest tricks down since they don't have to worry about throwing an unnatural trick if they don't want to, which could ultimately lead to more progression.
Jan 28 2022 11:14AM
4 0
profile picture
asparagus
Posts: 2489 - Karma: 28,369
Leave left and right tricks for slopestyle, big air is all about bucking the most insane stuff possible
Jan 28 2022 11:24AM
12 0
profile picture
Angioedema
Posts: 397 - Karma: 1,790
SSteezleThe judges at Xgames are terrible. It's not fair to the athletes who podium'd, or to Matej. Judges clearly don't even know the tricks the skiers are throwing anymore.


^^
Jan 28 2022 3:25PM
0 0
profile picture
jakeordie
Posts: 664 - Karma: 3,277
skiermanMember when future spins were a joke because everyone thought they were impossible?

Judas and Pilate did 180s in 33 AD
Jan 28 2022 3:31PM
6 0
profile picture
yungsteeze
Posts: 673 - Karma: 1,969
jakeordieJudas and Pilate did 180s in 33 AD


lol i doubt judas and pilate ever skied but skiing is thought to have existed since around 5,000 years ago so future spins must have been commonplace assuming anybody was catching some air
Jan 28 2022 3:39PM
2 1
profile picture
GrandThings
Posts: 3166 - Karma: 31,947
yungsteezelol i doubt judas and pilate ever skied but skiing is thought to have existed since around 5,000 years ago so future spins must have been commonplace assuming anybody was catching some air


John the Baptist did a 180 and people were like "damn spin to win huh"
Jan 28 2022 4:56PM
3 0
profile picture
marrows
Posts: 399 - Karma: 656
x games is whack regardless of this clown shit m8
Jan 28 2022 5:43PM
4 0
profile picture
armchair_skier
Posts: 2349 - Karma: 29,639
@AlexHall thoughts?
Jan 28 2022 6:11PM
4 0
All times are Eastern (-5)