Member of the Month

je_t.aime_canard
January, 2025

Online

Welcome to the Newschoolers forums! You may read the forums as a guest, however you must be a registered member to post. Register to become a member today!

Is Eileen Gu Competing for China Problematic?

profile picture
@LANTASKI
Posts: 633 - Karma: 1,730
Let me preface this first by saying I think Eileen Gu is an incredible athlete. Clearly she has taken women's skiing to another level and thats cool I guess for the people that are into women's skiing.

While I understand her decision to compete for China given her mother's nationality, her marketability in China as a Gold Winning Skier in a burgeoning snow sports market etc, I still question her judgement and the ethics of skiing for Nation with an Authoritarian Regime that imprisons its religious minorities in concentration camps, censors and restricts the basic human rights of its citizens.

I don't check NS as much as I did 20 years ago, but I find it hard to believe this is only rustlin my jimmies?

I find it disappointing that the switch from the US Ski Team to China is essentially a cash grab/sell out move and it is disappointing seeing these actions taken in a sport that was created by a bunch of dirtbags (I say that with the utmost reverence) who wanted to change skiing from the overbearing regulation and stifling nature of the FIS.

I guess we've officially gone the way of snowboarding
Dec 15 2021 4:48PM
155 18
profile picture
MiIfHunter
Posts: 3978 - Karma: 4,270
She is very mislead to say the least and yes it is problematic, but only to her own ignorance really. I mean most nations are boycotting the olympics anyways so nobody really gives a fuck in the larger scheme of things. The way she rationalizes her nationality speaks volumes.
Dec 15 2021 4:54PM
73 12
profile picture
Biffbarf
Posts: 7008 - Karma: 74,158
@LANTASKII don't check NS as much as I did 20 years ago, but I find it hard to believe this is only rustlin my jimmies?


It's way less hip to hate to hate on china now-a-days for some reason, even if they still commit unspeakable atrocities.
Dec 15 2021 4:57PM
68 7
profile picture
Professor-Modelo
Posts: 460 - Karma: 5,077
I could never support someone who was born elsewhere and made an elective decision to represent a country like China in the olympics. (North Korea excepted)

**This post was edited on Dec 15th 2021 at 5:07:59pm
Dec 15 2021 5:07PM
58 7
profile picture
Deez_Mcskis
Posts: 382 - Karma: 3,791
She's kinda hot ngl
Dec 15 2021 5:08PM
47 40
profile picture
@LANTASKI
Posts: 633 - Karma: 1,730
Dec 15 2021 5:11PM
67 2
profile picture
C.R.E.A.M
Posts: 2998 - Karma: 4,651
Impossible to know what someone's true motivations are, what pressures they are under, or what influences them.
Dec 15 2021 5:25PM
33 19
profile picture
hi_vis360
Posts: 5193 - Karma: 53,374
the olympics as a whole are problematic, this is a drop in the ocean
Dec 15 2021 5:27PM
87 2
profile picture
johnoble
Posts: 272 - Karma: 2,627
BiffbarfIt's way less hip to hate to hate on china now-a-days for some reason, even if they still commit unspeakable atrocities.


Nah it chill af to hate on the chinese government. all my homies hate winnie the pooh
Dec 15 2021 5:29PM
104 2
profile picture
Andi_G
Posts: 3088 - Karma: 15,125
Shes been traveling to and from China since 2 years old and its hard to say how connected she is or not to the culture without knowing the family. I still think its a marketing cash grab but thats not to say there aren't real legit reasons for her to compete under the chinese flag. She can do what she wants cause id imagine if china allowed dual citizenship then shed be a dual.

This shit was always gonna happen with the skiing being in the Olympics just like any other sport, she just happens to be super skilled so its a big deal.

If the jimmies being rustled has to do with humanitarian rights then its not like the US is a shining example either. Once you lift up the veil of patriotic propaganda and look critically at what the us does and has done globally its pretty funny that we think of ourselves as any sort of moral authority.

Not excusing china's human rights abuses cause theyre guilty of a ton but its bullshit to use them as a reason to judge her for a move that makes sense for her financially as well as culturally. Sucks to miss out on a good medal opportunity for the us but fuck it FIS sucks anyway
Dec 15 2021 6:06PM
81 12
profile picture
little1337
Posts: 8304 - Karma: 49,143
johnobleNah it chill af to hate on the chinese government. all my homies hate winnie the pooh


Dec 15 2021 6:09PM
120 2
profile picture
@LANTASKI
Posts: 633 - Karma: 1,730
AndrewGravesSVShes been traveling to and from China since 2 years old and its hard to say how connected she is or not to the culture without knowing the family. I still think its a marketing cash grab but thats not to say there aren't real legit reasons for her to compete under the chinese flag. She can do what she wants cause id imagine if china allowed dual citizenship then shed be a dual.

This shit was always gonna happen with the skiing being in the Olympics just like any other sport, she just happens to be super skilled so its a big deal.

If the jimmies being rustled has to do with humanitarian rights then its not like the US is a shining example either. Once you lift up the veil of patriotic propaganda and look critically at what the us does and has done globally its pretty funny that we think of ourselves as any sort of moral authority.

Not excusing china's human rights abuses cause theyre guilty of a ton but its bullshit to use them as a reason to judge her for a move that makes sense for her financially as well as culturally. Sucks to miss out on a good medal opportunity for the us but fuck it FIS sucks anyway


Not intending for this to devolve in to a human rights thread since its just one element, but despite its flaws the United States is still the beacon for civilization for the world.

Despite its issues the US still doesn't hold a candle to China's track record of human rights abuses and suppression of human rights

**This post was edited on Dec 15th 2021 at 6:12:09pm
Dec 15 2021 6:10PM
31 47
profile picture
Graham0596
Posts: 164 - Karma: 1,263
I don’t know her at all and shouldn’t really have an opinion but it just seems like cash & insta followers are her main motivations. Obviously she skis hard as hell and puts in the work. Just don’t like her vibe AT ALL.
Dec 15 2021 6:27PM
43 3
profile picture
gilbertressel
Posts: 639 - Karma: 8,508
@LANTASKIdespite its flaws the United States is still the beacon for civilization for the world.

LOL
Dec 15 2021 6:28PM
60 14
profile picture
Non_State_Actor
Posts: 4984 - Karma: 17,925
BiffbarfIt's way less hip to hate to hate on china now-a-days for some reason, even if they still commit unspeakable atrocities.


A lot of it is new cold war propaganda, same with the news about Russia. We don't get very much international news and it isn't very balanced so it's hard to tell where the truth lies sometimes.
Dec 15 2021 6:53PM
13 28
profile picture
Biffbarf
Posts: 7008 - Karma: 74,158
AndrewGravesSVShes been traveling to and from China since 2 years old and its hard to say how connected she is or not to the culture without knowing the family. I still think its a marketing cash grab but thats not to say there aren't real legit reasons for her to compete under the chinese flag. She can do what she wants cause id imagine if china allowed dual citizenship then shed be a dual.

This shit was always gonna happen with the skiing being in the Olympics just like any other sport, she just happens to be super skilled so its a big deal.

If the jimmies being rustled has to do with humanitarian rights then its not like the US is a shining example either. Once you lift up the veil of patriotic propaganda and look critically at what the us does and has done globally its pretty funny that we think of ourselves as any sort of moral authority.

Not excusing china's human rights abuses cause theyre guilty of a ton but its bullshit to use them as a reason to judge her for a move that makes sense for her financially as well as culturally. Sucks to miss out on a good medal opportunity for the us but fuck it FIS sucks anyway


To compare the atrocities of the US to China's is laughable. There's stains on our history without a doubt but you're comparing t ball vs major league here.
Dec 15 2021 7:09PM
55 17
profile picture
Non_State_Actor
Posts: 4984 - Karma: 17,925
BiffbarfTo compare the atrocities of the US to China's is laughable. There's stains on our history without a doubt but you're comparing t ball vs major league here.

Are you serious?
Dec 15 2021 7:13PM
18 38
profile picture
Biffbarf
Posts: 7008 - Karma: 74,158
mystery3Are you serious?


Yes. US doesn't hold a candle to China when it comes to human rights violations.
Dec 15 2021 7:15PM
61 15
profile picture
Jems
Posts: 7593 - Karma: 98,774
Imagine someone born in the bay area takes gold for china over you

id be hating very hard
Dec 15 2021 7:21PM
77 3
profile picture
Chunderface
Posts: 2546 - Karma: 9,981
mystery3A lot of it is new cold war propaganda, same with the news about Russia. We don't get very much international news and it isn't very balanced so it's hard to tell where the truth lies sometimes.


Lollll. Dude do you know anything about that China is doing? Like, today?
Dec 15 2021 7:36PM
26 2
profile picture
PeteMahn
Posts: 1317 - Karma: 3,383
Everyone is rooting for Kelly Sildaru in Slope since the last thing we wanna see is a girl who's an American citizen and has lived a majority of her life here compete for china. That being said who knows what the CCP said to her family...
Also Kelly got injured last year at X games so it would be nice to see her put down a clean run.
Dec 15 2021 7:45PM
48 1
profile picture
KilaTsunami
Posts: 3244 - Karma: 31,040
I’d switch just for one of those golden Dragon Jackets she got for doing so lol fukk the politics
Dec 15 2021 8:45PM
12 4
profile picture
Non_State_Actor
Posts: 4984 - Karma: 17,925
skeirmanLollll. Dude do you know anything about that China is doing? Like, today?


What do you want to talk about? Uyguhrs? Hong Kong? China's actions in its territorial waters aka the south China sea?

I'm not an apologist but the fear mongering in much of the western media is relentless.
Dec 15 2021 9:04PM
7 34
profile picture
Jems
Posts: 7593 - Karma: 98,774
mystery3What do you want to talk about? Uyguhrs? Hong Kong? China's actions in its territorial waters aka the south China sea?

I'm not an apologist but the fear mongering in much of the western media is relentless.


do you know how fucking stupid you sound??
Dec 15 2021 9:19PM
46 6
profile picture
skierman
Posts: 8452 - Karma: 8,102
Well to be fair, Xi doesn't have supporters storming the Capitol and smearing shit on the walls, less inflation and they're not having issues finding people to fill empty jobs. Eileen Gu is just picking a winner and I don't blame her for her correct choice.
Dec 15 2021 9:36PM
30 61
profile picture
@LANTASKI
Posts: 633 - Karma: 1,730
mystery3What do you want to talk about? Uyguhrs? Hong Kong? China's actions in its territorial waters aka the south China sea?

I'm not an apologist but the fear mongering in much of the western media is relentless.

i acnkowledge there is a point in most people’s lives where its cool to espouse some alternative political ideologies , but I guess the main question to ask you is :

Would you rather live under Chinese or US hegemony?

The answer is pretty obvious. Holla at your boi when you see caravans of migrants rusking it all for a chance to “make it “ in Ningbo

**This post was edited on Dec 15th 2021 at 9:37:59pm
Dec 15 2021 9:37PM
20 5
profile picture
Biffbarf
Posts: 7008 - Karma: 74,158
skiermanWell to be fair, Xi doesn't have supporters storming the Capitol and smearing shit on the walls, less inflation and they're not having issues finding people to fill empty jobs. Eileen Gu is just picking a winner and I don't blame her for her correct choice.


Dec 15 2021 9:39PM
66 0
profile picture
Non_State_Actor
Posts: 4984 - Karma: 17,925
Jemsdo you know how fucking stupid you sound??


@LANTASKIi acnkowledge there is a point in most people’s lives where its cool to espouse some alternative political ideologies , but I guess the main question to ask you is :

Would you rather live under Chinese or US hegemony?

The answer is pretty obvious. Holla at your boi when you see caravans of migrants rusking it all for a chance to “make it “ in Ningbo

**This post was edited on Dec 15th 2021 at 9:37:59pm


Is the kool-aid tasty?
Dec 15 2021 9:56PM
4 24
profile picture
doubleblackjack
Posts: 627 - Karma: 6,720
Lol does this really matter though
Dec 15 2021 10:03PM
10 6
profile picture
Chunderface
Posts: 2546 - Karma: 9,981
skiermanWell to be fair, Xi doesn't have supporters storming the Capitol and smearing shit on the walls, less inflation and they're not having issues finding people to fill empty jobs. Eileen Gu is just picking a winner and I don't blame her for her correct choice.


That's because they'd literally be killed, disappeared, or imprisoned for life if they tried.
Dec 15 2021 10:09PM
41 0
profile picture
keagan.karstens
Posts: 1621 - Karma: 35,142
God I love this app. Y’all are so entertaining
Dec 15 2021 10:29PM
30 2
profile picture
hunternay_10
Posts: 136 - Karma: 747
skiermanWell to be fair, Xi doesn't have supporters storming the Capitol and smearing shit on the walls, less inflation and they're not having issues finding people to fill empty jobs. Eileen Gu is just picking a winner and I don't blame her for her correct choice.


Dude is a fucking communist authoritarian regime. They can’t do that bc they will be killed.
Dec 15 2021 11:11PM
19 2
profile picture
hunternay_10
Posts: 136 - Karma: 747
skeirmanThat's because they'd literally be killed, disappeared, or imprisoned for life if they tried.


We are actively watching it happen with the Tennis player who has been missing for like two months now




side note my dislexia totally had me thinking you were commenting on your own post and I was hella confused

**This post was edited on Dec 15th 2021 at 11:15:00pm
Dec 15 2021 11:12PM
18 0
profile picture
TRVP_ANGEL
Posts: 12562 - Karma: 117,096
This thread going to make NS banned in China. I'll save us

Super Idol的笑容 都没你的甜 八月正午的阳光 都没你耀眼 热爱 105 °C的你 滴滴清纯的蒸馏水

Dec 15 2021 11:13PM
54 0
profile picture
armchair_skier
Posts: 2449 - Karma: 31,240
The Olympics is a fucking circus who cares.
Dec 15 2021 11:27PM
12 2
profile picture
scratchskier321
Posts: 2685 - Karma: 870
she chose to ski for china before she became a god, at the time she was unsure if she'd even make US team. ski for china, it was a lock.
Dec 15 2021 11:30PM
7 3
profile picture
Biffbarf
Posts: 7008 - Karma: 74,158
BiffbarfYes. US doesn't hold a candle to China when it comes to human rights violations.


mystery3Is the kool-aid tasty?


Real talk do you not believe this or?
Dec 15 2021 11:31PM
9 0
profile picture
musclehamster
Posts: 251 - Karma: 1,241
FIS is not core
Dec 15 2021 11:34PM
15 1
profile picture
marvin69
Posts: 63 - Karma: 656
until they put knuckle huck in the Olympics it will suck. I just want to see some baggy clothes and im sold ar ar ar
Dec 15 2021 11:37PM
15 3
profile picture
JimmyRecard
Posts: 242 - Karma: 2,552
BiffbarfIt's way less hip to hate to hate on china now-a-days for some reason, even if they still commit unspeakable atrocities.


It's not that it's less hip, it's that China is a huge economy that most organizations are too afraid to criticize. Look at Daryl Morey and the NBA - he tweeted in support of Hong Kong and China immediately erased the Houston Rockets from the internet and pulled games off of TV. Think the one tweet cost the NBA like $300 million.

Peng Shuai is a more recent example. WTA pulled out of China but most major sports leagues have been silent, they too are terrified of economic backlash.
Dec 15 2021 11:39PM
16 0
profile picture
Non_State_Actor
Posts: 4984 - Karma: 17,925
BiffbarfReal talk do you not believe this or?


I'm definitely trolling a bit but in all seriousness the news coverage in the US is horribly biased and the situation with both China and Russia is much more complicated than it is portrayed.

I'm not in favor of spending more taxpayer dollars on further funding the military build up to protect the US or any other country from the Chinese/Communist/Russian menace.
Dec 15 2021 11:41PM
9 7
profile picture
WoFlowz
Posts: 8043 - Karma: 63,873
I’d probably do it too if the check was big enough
Dec 15 2021 11:54PM
9 4
profile picture
jps2.0
Posts: 477 - Karma: 2,410
it was probably a smart move money wise, but china will probably lose interest in her after the olympics even if she wins medals, because they are not holding the olympics again and they probably 'bought' her as a chinese athlete to win at the home games.
Dec 16 2021 12:18AM
8 3
profile picture
Notaskibum
Posts: 849 - Karma: 4,007
This is fucked
Dec 16 2021 1:22AM
2 1
profile picture
Cream_Sauce
Posts: 482 - Karma: 1,561
@LANTASKI... the United States is still the beacon for civilization for the world....

It's so sad that americans actually believe this. The US is beacon for corrupt power and swindling your dumb fuck population.



This isn't a slight against the good half, it's a slight against the ignorant obese half of the population.
Dec 16 2021 1:25AM
18 23
profile picture
Biffbarf
Posts: 7008 - Karma: 74,158
Cream_SauceIt's so sad that americans actually believe this. The US is beacon for corrupt power and swindling your dumb fuck population.



This isn't a slight against the good half, it's a slight against the ignorant obese half of the population.


You're still trying to play sides how cute
Dec 16 2021 1:38AM
15 3
profile picture
Christian_Bale
Posts: 2078 - Karma: 23,451
@LANTASKIbut despite its flaws the United States is still the beacon for civilization for the world.

Do you think people from other countries believe that? The South American countries who had their governments overthrown in US/CIA-backed coups and the countries the US has invaded? I kinda doubt that they do. Not tryna be overly anti-American but let's be real here.
Dec 16 2021 1:42AM
23 4
profile picture
Jems
Posts: 7593 - Karma: 98,774
Cream_SauceIt's so sad that americans actually believe this. The US is beacon for corrupt power and swindling your dumb fuck population.



This isn't a slight against the good half, it's a slight against the ignorant obese half of the population.

not a lot of Americans believe this you’re just a dumbass who is generalizing
Dec 16 2021 1:49AM
13 8
profile picture
holzpflock
Posts: 44 - Karma: 427
Americans really think they are the epicenter of the earth. But hey u guys are not the ones to blame it's your shitty education-system and the even shittier media landscape in the US. Im not surprised when people think the US Government has only brought freedom to the world when at the same time they think Fox News is good journalism....

Speak to people from other continents about their view on the US and you will see that they might have a completly different picture than you have.

I'm not trying to say that all americans are dumb, thats just stupid. I just observed that some tend live in a bubble. Im also aware that most people do that to a certain extent.

Just try to get your information from as many different Sources as possible, it may change your opinion
Dec 16 2021 6:03AM
24 19
profile picture
Biffbarf
Posts: 7008 - Karma: 74,158
holzpflockAmericans really think they are the epicenter of the earth. But hey u guys are not the ones to blame it's your shitty education-system and the even shittier media landscape in the US. Im not surprised when people think the US Government has only brought freedom to the world when at the same time they think Fox News is good journalism....

Speak to people from other continents about their view on the US and you will see that they might have a completly different picture than you have.

I'm not trying to say that all americans are dumb, thats just stupid. I just observed that some tend live in a bubble. Im also aware that most people do that to a certain extent.

Just try to get your information from as many different Sources as possible, it may change your opinion


Wow you're right. I would have never thought this. Who would have thought different people from different places with different cultures would have different views. I also never knew to use more than a single source of news. Thanks for that, any other brain busters you have for us lowly muricans?
Dec 16 2021 7:39AM
26 4
profile picture
armchair_skier
Posts: 2449 - Karma: 31,240
Dec 16 2021 8:18AM
1 0
All times are Eastern (-5)