Member of the Month

je_t.aime_canard
January, 2025

Online

Welcome to the Newschoolers forums! You may read the forums as a guest, however you must be a registered member to post. Register to become a member today!

Brilliant idea, prove me wrong

profile picture
fries
Posts: 2978 - Karma: 7,521
I dont remember if i've posted about this before, but sometimes when you have a million dollar idea you just gotta share it with random internet strangers right?

Imagine skis with some sort of magnet inside, then your boots have magnets on the toes and heels for you to just "click on" by sticking to your skis. Your DIN would be determined by how strong the magnet is.

pros:
no more penetration by your FKS/look bindings
no need to mount skis when you buy them

cons:
binding industry collapses
getting violently attracted to rails when you go through the park
getting stick to the chairlift
ski flex would be killed (maybe the magnet should be broken into smaller slivers)
Prob would need an electromagnet

I think there are still some kinks in the idea but i'm willing to look past them. It's nothing major right?
POLL
Edit Poll
Votes:

Take care when editing a poll; Options should be similar to maintain vote integrity.

More options will be added automatically as you type. You must supply a question and at least two options. No HTML is allowed.

Nov 4 2019 6:30PM
13 0
profile picture
Price_Police
Posts: 444 - Karma: 1,786
*Matt Sterbenz has entered the chat*
Nov 4 2019 8:13PM
9 0
profile picture
fries
Posts: 2978 - Karma: 7,521
mattypeezus*Matt Sterbenz has entered the chat*


Tell me more
Nov 4 2019 10:17PM
2 0
profile picture
Biffbarf
Posts: 6894 - Karma: 73,326
Couple things.

Electromagnets are very heavy and require a lot of power, and the power supply would also be really heavy.

The force in a magnetic field decreases with distance very quickly, whereas the spring force of a binding increase linearly untill your boot releases. This means that the binding would have to have nearly 0 elasticity because the moment the boot/binding interface seperates even a little, you'd lose a significant amount of holding force.

I dig the idea though, I'm not trying to say it is something you shouldn't think about, those are just the hurdles I can think of. I think it is super rad to get the alternate binding discussion going.
Nov 4 2019 10:48PM
24 0
profile picture
fries
Posts: 2978 - Karma: 7,521
BiffbarfCouple things.

Electromagnets are very heavy and require a lot of power, and the power supply would also be really heavy.

The force in a magnetic field decreases with distance very quickly, whereas the spring force of a binding increase linearly untill your boot releases. This means that the binding would have to have nearly 0 elasticity because the moment the boot/binding interface seperates even a little, you'd lose a significant amount of holding force.

I dig the idea though, I'm not trying to say it is something you shouldn't think about, those are just the hurdles I can think of. I think it is super rad to get the alternate binding discussion going.


Time to pack up my stuff and leave
Nov 4 2019 11:40PM
15 0
profile picture
Sharko
Posts: 2274 - Karma: 4,100
friesTime to pack up my stuff and leave


Well, you had a good run
Nov 5 2019 1:52AM
11 0
profile picture
TRVP_ANGEL
Posts: 12554 - Karma: 116,926
it exists already, its called military grade duct tape
Nov 5 2019 2:04AM
7 1
profile picture
fries
Posts: 2978 - Karma: 7,521
SharkoWell, you had a good run


Exactly lmao
Nov 5 2019 2:07AM
2 0
profile picture
CatdickBojangles
Posts: 6232 - Karma: 63,322
What happens when you slide a rail? You would just stick.
Nov 5 2019 7:40AM
4 0
profile picture
Lemuel
Posts: 14530 - Karma: 10,985
I hate getting stick to chairlift.


OP grab some magnets off your drive and make a prototype.
Nov 5 2019 7:42AM
7 0
profile picture
fries
Posts: 2978 - Karma: 7,521
CatdickBojanglesWhat happens when you slide a rail? You would just stick.


This ski is not for hooligan park skiers btw
Nov 5 2019 9:00AM
6 0
profile picture
CatdickBojangles
Posts: 6232 - Karma: 63,322
friesThis ski is not for hooligan park skiers btw


What about jerrys getting stuck together on the chair?
Nov 5 2019 9:10AM
14 0
profile picture
SofaKingSick
Posts: 9446 - Karma: 62,559
Hmm okay

how about epoxy poured into the cracks of regular bindings

or maybe a steel bolt that goes through my actual foot
Nov 5 2019 9:38AM
9 0
profile picture
PsychicMigration
Posts: 2099 - Karma: 10,542
Interesting Idea but adjusting din would be a $1000 investment because you either need new skis or boots. Not sure how this would effect the core of skis and their performance but it probably wouldn't be good.
Nov 5 2019 9:40AM
3 0
profile picture
jupiterhenry
Posts: 140 - Karma: 598
How bout just regular bindings, but then electromagnets on the bottom of the skis that you could turn on and off with a little button on your pole? Then when you do stalls on anything metal, you can click it on and do the smooth criminal lean

Nov 5 2019 3:04PM
12 0
profile picture
xxACIDTRIPxx
Posts: 5980 - Karma: 8,176
What about super glue

Our skis with integrated boots
Nov 5 2019 4:13PM
3 1
profile picture
fries
Posts: 2978 - Karma: 7,521
jupiterhenryHow bout just regular bindings, but then electromagnets on the bottom of the skis that you could turn on and off with a little button on your pole? Then when you do stalls on anything metal, you can click it on and do the smooth criminal lean



Boom. New wave
Nov 5 2019 4:15PM
4 0
profile picture
shred.stickz
Posts: 279 - Karma: 1,715
_GHOSTWhat about super glue

Our skis with integrated boots


Skis with integrated boots... might as well just throw away my ACLs now but I'm listening
Nov 5 2019 7:56PM
6 0
profile picture
Bdoobz
Posts: 838 - Karma: 4,894
_GHOSTWhat about super glue

Our skis with integrated boots


Ask Lindsey Vonn's knees about that idea
Nov 5 2019 8:00PM
7 0
profile picture
freestyler540
Posts: 13140 - Karma: 19,339
These things would be stupid heavy. You need the magnet, copper wire and battery. To hold your weight, they would have to be a neodinium alloy, wrapped with copper. Say you use hollow circular magnet, you have wrap it up pretty densly. The you gotta power it...and you gonna need more that a 1.5v battery.

plus magnets detatch from sliding. Your boots would really just slide off. Pulling them apart is hard, sliding is easy. Movies poorly portrays magnets...
jupiterhenryHow bout just regular bindings, but then electromagnets on the bottom of the skis that you could turn on and off with a little button on your pole? Then when you do stalls on anything metal, you can click it on and do the smooth criminal lean

Nov 5 2019 8:14PM
2 0
profile picture
jupiterhenry
Posts: 140 - Karma: 598
Props for the real-life scientific response but I was playing
Nov 5 2019 8:31PM
5 0
profile picture
freestyler540
Posts: 13140 - Karma: 19,339
jupiterhenryProps for the real-life scientific response but I was playing

It was a decent shot though. But Im an engineer; a dream killer
Nov 5 2019 8:34PM
3 0
profile picture
jupiterhenry
Posts: 140 - Karma: 598
I mean, a bizzaro rig could be built for one stupid shot do
Nov 6 2019 9:12PM
0 0
profile picture
dolanslebensraum
Posts: 5959 - Karma: -13,100
BiffbarfCouple things.

Electromagnets are very heavy and require a lot of power, and the power supply would also be really heavy.

The force in a magnetic field decreases with distance very quickly, whereas the spring force of a binding increase linearly untill your boot releases. This means that the binding would have to have nearly 0 elasticity because the moment the boot/binding interface seperates even a little, you'd lose a significant amount of holding force.

I dig the idea though, I'm not trying to say it is something you shouldn't think about, those are just the hurdles I can think of. I think it is super rad to get the alternate binding discussion going.


Unfortunately this.
Magnets dont work like springs
Nov 6 2019 11:14PM
1 0
profile picture
fries
Posts: 2978 - Karma: 7,521
DolanReloadedUnfortunately this.
Magnets dont work like springs

Spring + magnet

spragnet
Nov 7 2019 1:53AM
3 0
profile picture
ScootSkiLyfe
Posts: 1043 - Karma: 5,616
SofaKingSickHmm okay

how about epoxy poured into the cracks of regular bindings

or maybe a steel bolt that goes through my actual foot


This
Nov 7 2019 3:28AM
1 0
profile picture
KilaTsunami
Posts: 3237 - Karma: 30,991
I Love the magnets idea bro. And it’s too bad about the “science” or whatever thats holding it back,

but I too just had a great idea I had to hop online and say...

Ski resorts should put those cameras that roller coasters have in the park! Like in the jump line, or in cool spots and u can buy them later for a ridiculous ski resort type price
Dec 10 2020 12:40AM
4 0
profile picture
SlitherySnake
Posts: 1168 - Karma: 8,616
jupiterhenryHow bout just regular bindings, but then electromagnets on the bottom of the skis that you could turn on and off with a little button on your pole? Then when you do stalls on anything metal, you can click it on and do the smooth criminal lean



bahahahaha yes please
Dec 10 2020 4:32PM
1 0
All times are Eastern (-5)