• Forums
  • Ski Gabber
  • A few questions about framerate, shutterspeed and skimovies.

Member of the Month

KilaTsunami
October, 2024

Online

Welcome to the Newschoolers forums! You may read the forums as a guest, however you must be a registered member to post. Register to become a member today!

A few questions about framerate, shutterspeed and skimovies.

profile picture
MarkusFin
Posts: 366 - Karma: 2,623
Recently I've started fooling around with video a lot more, and I've seen a lot of people advocating for the 180 degree shutterspeed rule (30fps, shoot in 60/1 shutterspeed) in normal videography. However I couldn't find anything about the subject when talking about skiing.

Now I've noticed that when I see certain mountainbiking videos, the video ends up being a bit jittery at times, and too blurry, to the point where it's almost painful to watch.

Also I personally find 24 fps to be too little for ski videos that I've made myself, as you can too clearly see the frames.

- What framerates are most ski videos exported in?

- Do they always follow the 180 degree rule in professional ski videos?
Oct 31 2019 7:32AM
1 1
profile picture
PsychicMigration
Posts: 2099 - Karma: 10,540
180 degrees distorts the image so much I think your spewing when you say that. Iv found 1080 or 4K at 60 to be good and 120 for slow motion shots.
Oct 31 2019 8:38AM
0 2
profile picture
MarkusFin
Posts: 366 - Karma: 2,623
DummyBears180 degrees distorts the image so much I think your spewing when you say that.


Shitty joke or bad troll?
Oct 31 2019 9:25AM
1 2
profile picture
Aric
Posts: 190 - Karma: 851
I’m not an expert but I will be playing around with this to I think that a little over 120 when shooting 60 might give you a nice crisper image I mean we are moving a lot faster than the average walking speed so
Oct 31 2019 11:54AM
3 0
profile picture
Aric
Posts: 190 - Karma: 851
Just wait until you get out there and play around a bit you will probably find that there are different scenarios that require different FPS and SS like say if you want to make someone look like they are going faster you can turn down SS and if you are going to freeze frame a spot in the clip bump up SS
Oct 31 2019 11:57AM
1 0
profile picture
eheath
Posts: 61601 - Karma: 123,027
It comes down to preference, most filmmakers will use a "180 degree" shutter angle aka double your frame rate. When I first started filming, i didnt care about my shutter speed, would shoot 1/500 or higher sometimes, tbh the video doesn't look that different. 95% of people watching your video wont notice, but you will so its up to you.

Most filmmakers export 24fps as well, I've seen plenty of people upload 30 or 60 fps videos online, again up to your preference.

To me, filming with a 180 degree shutter and exporting 24fps is the way to go. If you need to break the 180 degree shutter rule, its okay, if you want to export 30fps/60fps to make it look smoother, thats okay as well.
Oct 31 2019 12:47PM
6 0
profile picture
MarkusFin
Posts: 366 - Karma: 2,623
eheathMost filmmakers export 24fps as well, I've seen plenty of people upload 30 or 60 fps videos online, again up to your preference.

Cheers! I just found out the kimbosessions video (https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=vnF9yOnZUHY&t=179s) is exported in 50p and I haven't thought of that video as any different than any other ski vids, so I guess most people wont notice a difference.

I guess if you have a ton of motion, camera movement etc, it might be better with 50p, and if you have a lot of stabilized shots then 25 / 24 is probably better.

Gonna experiment a bit this winter and see which one I prefer.
Oct 31 2019 1:08PM
1 0
profile picture
eheath
Posts: 61601 - Karma: 123,027
MarkusFinCheers! I just found out the kimbosessions video (https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=vnF9yOnZUHY&t=179s) is exported in 50p and I haven't thought of that video as any different than any other ski vids, so I guess most people wont notice a difference.

I guess if you have a ton of motion, camera movement etc, it might be better with 50p, and if you have a lot of stabilized shots then 25 / 24 is probably better.

Gonna experiment a bit this winter and see which one I prefer.


I only shoot 60fps, as so many other filmers. Filming specific shots at certain frame rates is a good practice, but I've never found it worthwhile.
Oct 31 2019 1:27PM
2 0
profile picture
isaacwrong
Posts: 2287 - Karma: 17,507
If you're filming sports, capturing high paced action and going to be slowing down in post you wouldn't want to follow 180 rule. When shooting 60fps I aim for a shutter of 1/500. Less motion blur, personal preference tho
Oct 31 2019 2:14PM
2 0
profile picture
eheath
Posts: 61601 - Karma: 123,027
isaacwrongIf you're filming sports, capturing high paced action and going to be slowing down in post you wouldn't want to follow 180 rule. When shooting 60fps I aim for a shutter of 1/500. Less motion blur, personal preference tho


Yeah if you're gonna shoot say 120fps, 1/240 would be the "proper" way to do it, but I shoot 60fps 1/125, sometime 1/160 but never any higher or else its just a very clear picture, which some people like.
Oct 31 2019 2:30PM
1 0
profile picture
IanAvery-Leaf
Posts: 9931 - Karma: 9,399
I treat the 180° shutter "rule" as a rule and not a suggestion 95% of the time, and also film in the framerate that's needed for the final exported shot (so no 60fps filming when the end product isn't slo motion). It makes for way more stressful days of filming due to constantly thinking about and switching around framerates, and keeping the shutter speed adjusted to 180°, but IMO the efforts are always worth it. I can otherwise easily tell when footage wasn't shot with the "proper" framerate and/or shutter speed and it def bugs me. Also always 24fps export, never strayed from that
Oct 31 2019 2:47PM
3 0
profile picture
bob_dole
Posts: 4078 - Karma: 1,580
MarkusFinCheers! I just found out the kimbosessions video (https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=vnF9yOnZUHY&t=179s) is exported in 50p and I haven't thought of that video as any different than any other ski vids, so I guess most people wont notice a difference.

I guess if you have a ton of motion, camera movement etc, it might be better with 50p, and if you have a lot of stabilized shots then 25 / 24 is probably better.

Gonna experiment a bit this winter and see which one I prefer.


Those movies are done in 25/50p because it was all in Euro land. Europe and much of the rest of the world generally shoot in PAL (25 or 50) whereas the US, Japan, and a few other places tend to go with the 24,30 or 60 framerate situations (NTSC). This is because of the way that the power gets pumped to monitors / TVs. Here, in the US, it is a 60-hertz signal, so the cameras would tend to want to shoot around that refresh rate. In PAL countries, the power comes through in a 50-hertz signal so that's why they shoot in 25 or 50 fps.

So bottomline... trying out 25 or 50 fps on your footage here in the states will only end up looking weird on TVs when you play it back. But maybe you go one a sweet europe vacation and impress all the ladies at the condo...so who knows.
Oct 31 2019 3:08PM
1 0
profile picture
suup
Posts: 1485 - Karma: 4,367
threads
Oct 31 2019 3:11PM
0 0
profile picture
MarkusFin
Posts: 366 - Karma: 2,623
bob_doleThose movies are done in 25/50p because it was all in Euro land.

I know :P I'm european. The issue is that in the states you film in 30 right, and europe it's 25, making it even more stuttery here than in the U.S. This is why I was wondering about the framerate use, since I can't really use NTSC unless the video is strictly in daylight.
Oct 31 2019 4:10PM
0 0
All times are Eastern (-5)