Member of the Month

hi_vis360
November, 2024

Online

Welcome to the Newschoolers forums! You may read the forums as a guest, however you must be a registered member to post. Register to become a member today!

ACL graft type

profile picture
e.wait
Posts: 869 - Karma: 1,954
Patellar tendon or cadaver??? I'm told that the patellar tendon has the lowest rate of failure (by about 1-2%), but recovery is significantly easier with the cadaver option. I've also heard that patellar tendon patients tend to experience more anterior knee pain post-op. I have a fairly high pain tolerance, so I'm leaning towards the patellar tendon--but if anyone has some anecdotes that would help inform my decision, please share. Anyone have both done? i.e. patellar first, then cadaver after a re-tear.
Apr 7 2017 2:29PM
10 0
profile picture
eheath
Posts: 61645 - Karma: 123,447
I did a patellar graft when I had my ACL surgery (11 years ago) my doctor seemed to think it was best, I know people who have done all different types. I don't think it'll make a huge difference either way, its all about how well you recover in PT.
Apr 7 2017 2:38PM
2 0
profile picture
safety.third
Posts: 218 - Karma: 463
I did a hamstring graft for me ACL, and I'm happy with it. I've had no pain or issues at the site they harvested tissue. That was about a year ago, and now I'm deadlifting/doing hamstring movements the same as always.

Just make you have a good surgeon and really hop on therapy.
Apr 7 2017 6:06PM
2 0
profile picture
Deepskier
Posts: 3267 - Karma: 4,832
Ive sprained my patellar and MCL never blew them though so Im not sure I can help you.
Apr 7 2017 11:20PM
0 0
profile picture
skierman
Posts: 8369 - Karma: 7,576
Get the dead person's tendon. They won't be using it.
Apr 7 2017 11:47PM
2 0
profile picture
TheHamburglar
Posts: 3895 - Karma: 3,317
Who wouldn't get the cadaver? I got one and its fucking sweet
Apr 8 2017 12:15AM
1 0
profile picture
90053
Posts: 2565 - Karma: 3,728
Hype

Get the one your preferred doctor is most practised in

Quality of surgeon = better graft > type of graft
Apr 8 2017 12:45AM
0 0
profile picture
mikemurda
Posts: 93 - Karma: -116
Patellar Tendon, thats what Adrian Peterson got.
Apr 8 2017 9:01AM
1 0
profile picture
Lemuel
Posts: 14499 - Karma: 10,719
e.waitAnyone have both done? i.e. patellar first, then cadaver after a re-tear.


That's me. Cadaver was much easier to rehab, but it isn't as strong (apparently). Not too much knee pain, it does get achy sometimes but no big. Biggest thing really is keeping up with PT. They were thinking of taking my patellar from my other knee the second time around, but we decided to save that one for the chance of my left one blowing out, since my track record isn't good haha.
Apr 9 2017 9:34AM
1 0
profile picture
dan4060
Posts: 1458 - Karma: 847
I did mine about 13 years ago and got a patellar tendon. It has been great, but the rehab is not easy. Whatever you choose just get after it with the PT.
Apr 10 2017 11:57AM
0 0
profile picture
danbrown
Posts: 11939 - Karma: 21,828
hamstring. my doctor is the us freeski surgeon/team doctor. he didn't give me any other option.
Apr 10 2017 1:12PM
0 0
profile picture
arnie_grape
Posts: 3451 - Karma: 11,688
I had a patellar graft. that was about 4 years ago and my knee feels great most of the time. skiing better than ever these days. my knee still gets achy from time to time but stretching always fixes it.

right after surgery was really rough though, could barely get out of bed for 2 weeks. but I had both menisci done at the same time.
Apr 10 2017 1:24PM
0 0
profile picture
e.wait
Posts: 869 - Karma: 1,954
thanks for all the responses. probably going for the patellar tendon since my doc seems to favor it.
Apr 10 2017 9:43PM
0 0
profile picture
yelsel
Posts: 12967 - Karma: 3,451
ebotdzI did a hamstring graft for me ACL, and I'm happy with it. I've had no pain or issues at the site they harvested tissue. That was about a year ago, and now I'm deadlifting/doing hamstring movements the same as always.

Just make you have a good surgeon and really hop on therapy.


same here and I'm glad my doctor went that route
Apr 11 2017 9:56AM
0 0
All times are Eastern (-5)