Replying to Is a 505 deadlift impressive to you guys?

Alright, not tryna be a douchebag or anything and flaunt my gym achievements, but I recently hit a 505 lbs deadlift. I am 17, turning 18 in July, and currently am chasing my baseball dream as a pitcher. I have an pretty good offer to Chico State for baseballa and a whole bunch of JC's have shown interest. Anyways, when I do tell people I deadlifted 505 lbs they seem to blow it off and try to 1 up me with their benchpress, knowing I am a pitcher and can't bench. Is this jealousy or is a 505 deadlift not that impressive. I am 6'2 230 and was using a trap bar with 5 plates on each side.