J.D.First, when has it not been "outlawed" to be racist and homophobic? That's been a rule since, literally, 2006 or so. Possibly earlier.
We just made this change to the rules to reduce the bullshit and remove the people propogating the bullshit. The trend has been positive and we haven't even finished doing what needs doing yet. I figured it would take into the winter to see a marked improvement.
In other words, your "let it fly" concept has been what we've done for 2+ years and it's resulted in the forum becoming complete garbage. Why would we go back to that when things are already slowly but gradually improving?
-yeah? i said i agree with that part. i liked it when they started banning for using N---- and f----
-my point was beyond that, yeah we'd like to see a little less BS in the forums but my point is that you need to be careful not to over do it, as bishop is obviously addressing with asking what is "too soft"
i think beyond certain (nearly) universally agreed upon rules e.g. no calling people n-----, it's way too subjective to make any decent rules about. a lot of what we all talk about is subjective. an occasional irreverent "OP's mom" joke is funny in the right situation. ten of them aren't. an entire derailed thread over it sucks. we all agree on that, but how would you mod that objectively? maybe we have to take the bad with the good
further, i am really not of the opinion that there was some golden age when the forums were some bastion of thoughtful and well balanced discussion and repartee. ive been on these forums since 2001ish and while the memes and general environment change over time, i'm of the opinion that there has always been a similar makeup of good comedy, good discussion, and bullshit. i think it's maybe changed in form over the years but that's it. threads were ruined by pissy fights and stupid in-jokes in 2001, in 2006, and in 2014. maybe there's more 4chan esque stuff nowadays but whatever, that's a natural occurrence as the internet grows. like i said, you gotta take the bad with the good sometimes...
more importantly, it's propagate* you stupid $%&## #$*#$&!! something something your mom