Welcome to the Newschoolers forums! You may read the forums as a guest, however you must be a registered member to post. Register to become a member today!
I agree with the OP to a large extent, but the difference here is that the olympic slopestyle event is just one contest so whoever has the hot hand right before the games is going to get the nod more often over someone with more consistent results over a longer period of time. If you were putting together a team whose results were going to be combined for an overall team score or something like that, then yes you would definitely want Tom over Joss because of his consistency. When it's a one shot contest, where only individual competitors receive medals, you want the guy who has a lot of confidence and is skiing well right at that moment, and in this case Joss just lit it up at Park City.
The coaches need to base their decision on who gives them the best chance to win the gold medal on the day of the event, not the person who has had the more prolific career or even the better results over the last year (which is counterintutitive, I know). With that said, it must have been such a hard decision to make and I would've hated to be in that room.