Why would it scare people away? It's not like it's publicly available information -- just the staff have access to it. And anyways, the "Members Online" sidebar shows how often someone is online. And honestly, if someone is "scared" that Doug and I know they browse Newschoolers... well let's just say they have bigger problems to deal with.
We've had IP checks for a long time now, and they wont' be going anywhere anytime soon. They are almost integral with dealing with a lot of issues such as:
- IP banning spammers / trolls / etc.
- Regulating upvotes / downvotes
- Fixing commonly reported bugs
- Retrieving stolen llama heads
- Dealing with more serious issues such as threats or illegal activity
The fact that we've had them in place for a while and that most people have no idea clearly shows we're not abusing them...