Replying to 4xl Black dog eat dog OR 5xl Eggplant lohi?

4xl black jiberish dog eat dog zip up in real good condition with a couple minor flaws zipper length: 38

OR

5xl jiberish eggplant lohi pullover GREAT condition no flaws with a zipper length of 38....... Which one do you guys think is more valuable? As far as how much money they would go for and what they will be worth in the future if kept in great condition, just curious I know these pieces are both very sought after and desired in the NS community I was wondering what you guys think is more valuable?