I can confirm Caylors are a fine ski and the r2s are nice skis too. But having skied both back to back I would have to say Caylors are the superior ski. Before I bought my Caylors, I looked at the Chets. But I opted for the Caylors because I knew I'd appreciate their stiffer flex, and being a bigger guy, I was worried I'd find the Chets too soft in certain situations. To be honest I couldnt be more satisfied with my Caylors, I've now spent >100 days on them, so heres a loose collection of my thoughts: -
http://aslansskiblog.blogspot.co.uk/2013/03/on3p-caylor-ski-review.html?m=1 (sorry about the clicky, or lack of it, I'm on mobile)