• Forums
  • Non-Ski Gabber
  • Bill introduced in North Carolina to create official state religion, which also states each state is sovereign

Member of the Month

KilaTsunami
October, 2024

Online

Welcome to the Newschoolers forums! You may read the forums as a guest, however you must be a registered member to post. Register to become a member today!

Bill introduced in North Carolina to create official state religion, which also states each state is sovereign

profile picture
*TURBONERD*
Posts: 15081 - Karma: 9,157
Full article: http://www.huffingtonpost.com/2013/04/03/north-carolina-religion-bill_n_3003401.html
Republican North Carolina state legislators have proposed allowing an official state religion in a measure that would declare the state exempt from the Constitution and court rulings.

The bill, filed Monday by two GOP lawmakers from Rowan County and backed by nine other Republicans, says each state "is sovereign" and courts cannot block a state "from making laws respecting an establishment of religion." The legislation was filed in response to a lawsuit to stop county commissioners in Rowan County from opening meetings with a Christian prayer, wral.com reported.
That's a short excerpt for the TL;DR crowd. Does anybody think there's any sort of legal plausibility for this? It goes directly against the US Constitution as I understand it.
Apr 3 2013 7:24PM
34 13
profile picture
Arabian
Posts: 682 - Karma: 1,079
...which will be promptly defeated by the Constitution on the grounds that IT'S NOT CONSTITUTIONAL.
Apr 3 2013 7:25PM
7 1
profile picture
ILLinoisance
Posts: 3527 - Karma: 5,398
What does that matter?

#YOLO
Apr 3 2013 7:26PM
1 2
profile picture
Granby_killdozer
Posts: 2380 - Karma: -11,976
lol inb4 nc bashing
Apr 3 2013 7:27PM
0 0
profile picture
1337
Posts: 31054 - Karma: 29,231
I LOL'd
Apr 3 2013 7:29PM
0 0
profile picture
Ben.
Posts: 21463 - Karma: 683
I love that half of the conservatives who claim to love the constitution actually have no idea how it works.
Apr 3 2013 7:31PM
0 0
profile picture
*TURBONERD*
Posts: 15081 - Karma: 9,157
I do think it's a little humorous that the same group of individuals who cite the constitution for gun rights (a supporter of the bill recently also introduced a pro-concealed-weapons amendment to the state constitution) are clearly going directly against it in this case.
Apr 3 2013 7:32PM
1 1
profile picture
Pancake_Fucker
Posts: 1842 - Karma: 1,909
America is weird. I go play hockey now.
Apr 3 2013 7:33PM
1 0
profile picture
Spagett+
Posts: 3499 - Karma: 14,884
Petition to ban the state of North Carolina
Apr 3 2013 7:38PM
2 2
profile picture
ILLinoisance
Posts: 3527 - Karma: 5,398
I find it equally humorous that the same side who says a woman should be able to choose what she does to her own body in terms of abortion is the same side that banned a person's right to choose to eat trans fats in NYC.
Apr 3 2013 7:44PM
2 0
profile picture
Pancake_Fucker
Posts: 1842 - Karma: 1,909
I thought you Americans wanted more land, not less.
Apr 3 2013 7:48PM
0 1
profile picture
*TURBONERD*
Posts: 15081 - Karma: 9,157
Fair. I'll certainly concede that point as I don't want to get into a wider argument in this thread.
Apr 3 2013 7:50PM
0 0
profile picture
alex=
Posts: 1738 - Karma: 2,835
This. Rowan county is an hour away from where I'm at right now, and they are fucking DUMBASSES
Apr 3 2013 7:50PM
0 0
profile picture
.frenchy
Posts: 18221 - Karma: 12,321
Petition to ban the state of North Carolina: Denied.
Apr 3 2013 7:52PM
1 1
profile picture
Huck_Norris
Posts: 11487 - Karma: 18,627
Not to mention that it applies to everyone, not just them personally. Facepalmsville.

Apr 3 2013 7:58PM
1 1
profile picture
Granby_killdozer
Posts: 2380 - Karma: -11,976
yeah... because a couple law makers in some ass backward, bum fuck nowhere county represent the entire state's population... go fuck your self!
Apr 3 2013 7:59PM
1 0
profile picture
cydwhit
Posts: 5070 - Karma: 43,007
Hate to say it but since when has that actually mattered? Constitution gets "reinterpreted" and pushed aside all the time
Apr 3 2013 8:00PM
0 0
profile picture
Zimmerman
Posts: 6992 - Karma: 1,021
The hypocrisy is off the charts!
Apr 3 2013 8:02PM
1 1
profile picture
ILLinoisance
Posts: 3527 - Karma: 5,398
No argument. I'll say that both sides have some major flaws in their ideology.
Apr 3 2013 8:07PM
2 1
profile picture
cydwhit
Posts: 5070 - Karma: 43,007
also no hate but how is it necessarily unconstitutional? The first amendment says:

Congress shall make no law respecting an establishment of religion, or prohibiting the free exercise thereof; or abridging the freedom of speech, or of the press; or the right of the people peaceably to assemble, and to petition the Government for a redress of grievances.
I dont think that really shoots this down, I believe that the only other semi relevant clause is about no religious test for office, this is just off the top of my head so feel free to correct me
Apr 3 2013 8:12PM
0 0
profile picture
MothaHucker
Posts: 4678 - Karma: 2,591
dear lord I'm glad my liberal family moved out of that shit hole of a state...
Apr 3 2013 8:15PM
0 0
profile picture
Mr.Sloth
Posts: 5091 - Karma: 13,469
Signed. They're little shitters
Apr 3 2013 8:16PM
1 2
profile picture
Rachy
Posts: 4355 - Karma: 2,761
Apparently my family took their place.

Multi-racial atheist family for the win! Can't wait to have my mom call me about this one.
Apr 3 2013 8:20PM
0 0
profile picture
Wulfty
Posts: 344 - Karma: 1,876
Lol politics. I'll go back to living in a cave now.
Apr 3 2013 8:33PM
0 0
profile picture
GayWolf420
Posts: 37372 - Karma: 119,840
America!
Apr 3 2013 8:50PM
0 0
profile picture
Stose
Posts: 7109 - Karma: 4,123
And then we entered the 21st century
Apr 3 2013 9:29PM
0 0
profile picture
*TURBONERD*
Posts: 15081 - Karma: 9,157
It's widely accepted that the first part of that means that Congress shall pass no law creating a hierarchy of religions in any way.
Apr 3 2013 9:42PM
0 0
profile picture
cydwhit
Posts: 5070 - Karma: 43,007
Yep, right with you, Is Congress doing this? No, I don't think so. This comes across as more of a states' rights issue than a constitution issue to me. Too often people say "Well the constitution says church and state are separate" when they actually need to read the thing. I'm not trying to stir up the pot here, just trying to look at what the Constitution says on the subject since it has been called in as the authority. Honestly I think they have a right to advance this bill, and whether it is passed or not is not a matter of constitutionality. Again, I am not trying to start a church and state argument but rather clarify the constitutionality of this bill.
Apr 3 2013 9:52PM
0 0
profile picture
jibcrew1
Posts: 1505 - Karma: 522
god my state is fucking retarded
Apr 3 2013 9:52PM
0 0
profile picture
lands11
Posts: 1818 - Karma: 1,677
Did two people from different political parties just come to an agreement in 4 posts on NS? You two should run our country. +k to both of you
Apr 3 2013 9:53PM
1 0
profile picture
cydwhit
Posts: 5070 - Karma: 43,007
Seriously, that was great!
Apr 3 2013 9:55PM
0 0
profile picture
*TURBONERD*
Posts: 15081 - Karma: 9,157
Unless it's not specifically listed as a power of Congress (and this is, albeit as something they cannot do), then it's not a states' rights issue. Again, that's how I understand it and I'm no Gov major or anything, so feel free to correct me.
Apr 3 2013 10:41PM
0 0
profile picture
Chron_Rabbit
Posts: 988 - Karma: 1,567
I wish the United States government would declare Mormon influence over the state government in Utah unconstitutional. Them niggaz is crazy
Apr 3 2013 10:45PM
0 0
profile picture
cydwhit
Posts: 5070 - Karma: 43,007
Me neither but the tenth amendment says:

The powers not delegated to the United States by the Constitution, nor prohibited by it to the States, are reserved to the States respectively, or to the people.

In my understanding the constitution is a comprehensive list of government powers but not of the people's rights.

Thanks for the civility
Apr 3 2013 10:51PM
0 0
profile picture
*TURBONERD*
Posts: 15081 - Karma: 9,157
I feel like you're saying what I am, honestly. The 'establishing a religion' is expressly prohibited by the Constitution, so it falls under something not reserved to the States or to the people. So, the government has no power to do this.

No problem, I appreciate the civility on your end as well.
Apr 3 2013 11:39PM
0 0
profile picture
Ben.
Posts: 21463 - Karma: 683
However contrary to popular belief states are subject to federal law. North Carolina isn't "sovereign".
Apr 3 2013 11:40PM
0 0
profile picture
cydwhit
Posts: 5070 - Karma: 43,007
Yes, my distinction is in congress establishing the religion as opposed to the state doing it. I also felt like if people were just going to say " well they're dumb, the constitution says they can't do that" we should look at the relevant parts of the constitution. I think it all comes down to this whole "sovereign state" thing, not necessarily what agenda that state is trying to push
Apr 3 2013 11:47PM
0 0
profile picture
fujarome
Posts: 8630 - Karma: 1,561
There's also the supremacy clause.

Basically, if the constitution says you can't do it, you can't do it.

Will be interesting to see how this progresses though
Apr 3 2013 11:49PM
0 0
profile picture
*TURBONERD*
Posts: 15081 - Karma: 9,157
Like Ben said, no state within the US is sovereign; they're only independent to the point where they begin to violate federal law. Establishing this type of law would be in clear violation of the Constitution, which is federal law.
Apr 3 2013 11:50PM
0 0
profile picture
Ben.
Posts: 21463 - Karma: 683
Precisely. As far as I can tell this will be thrown out on that notion.
Apr 3 2013 11:51PM
0 0
profile picture
Italian.Stallion
Posts: 564 - Karma: 101
*ahem* 14th amendment *ahem*
Apr 3 2013 11:53PM
0 0
profile picture
alex=
Posts: 1738 - Karma: 2,835
Everyone here in NC is a rich white republican basically. The people who aren't rich and white don't even vote it seems like. All the politicians I see are rich white and GOP
Apr 4 2013 12:59AM
0 0
All times are Eastern (-5)