I'm about your height and quite a bit heavier and went with the 194 New Lifes because they are supposed to be quite a bit stiffer. Think old Hellbents, but stiff. I've got a friend who's about the same size as you and was looking at EP's a couple of years ago (he ended up going with Hellbents) and he was told right off the bat that he was going to overpower them. I think EP is a a pretty small dude. I think EP's would be fun to mess around with, but from what I've heard, I think you would likely find them way too soft.
I'll be out on my New Life's for the first time this weekend, so I'll let you know how they are.