Replying to Punching out narrow boots?

First day on my new/old raichles today. Got new liners and a footbed, and they felt awesome in the store, and when I wore them around last night, and when I put them on this morning, but by the time I got up to the top of the lift, I could hardly feel the outside edges of the widest part of my foot. It was incredibly painful, and I had to go inside every other run to thaw my feet out. The boots fit super well lengthwise, they fit my calves well, I like the flex, but I need them to be a bit wider.

Anyone have experience with punching boots, is it worth it? Or should I just look for a wider shell :(