Welcome to the Newschoolers forums! You may read the forums as a guest, however you must be a registered member to post. Register to become a member today!
I don't think he was saying that he has a cake devouring body-- he was speaking from the point of view of an overweight female.
here, I've translated since I understand moron:
"Seriously? She's not like anorexic skinny or anything. It's fucking called being healthy. I can't stand all the bullshit people say about real women having curves and "marilyn monroe is super hot because she's fat-- I'm proud of my cake devouring body"...trying to make it ok to be fat and unhealthy.
Girls that are physically active and eat very healthy look like that. Girls that eat fast food and consume gallons worth of beer a week aren't hot and aren't healthy."
jesus dude, arguing that that girl is underweight or "too skinny" is not the same thing as arguing for obesity. And honestly, it doesn't matter how much knowledge you have when you go around making uninformed comments. I obviously only have what you've said to go by. And I assumed you had no knowledge when you said "girls that are physically active and eat very healthy look like that." This just isn't true. Few do, actually.
I can't know the body fat percentage of the girl in question, although it would appear--athletic or otherwise-- taht is is on the low end and she is also lacking muscle. In terms of BMI she is clearly underweight. I viewed the video that the gif came from and I would guess the girl to be between 5'0" and 5'6"-- that being said, you can see what women look like at different weights/heights here:
I did a quick search and this is what 5'3", 85 pounds looks like-- similar to the girl in the gif.
If you look at the girls who are 5'3" and closer to 100 pounds, they are clearly less skinny than our gif girl in question.
The BMI for a girl who is 5'3" and 85 pounds is 15.1. The normal healthy weight range for a 5'3" girl is 18.5-24.9, or 105-140 pounds. Making the girl in question approximately 20 pounds from even the low end of a normal healthy weight. Go ahead and try to tell me she's in the healthy BMI range-- you'd just kidding yourself.
Now, she could just be naturally skinny and have a high metabolism, but that wouldnt make her healthy per se. She could also be skinny from malnutrition in which case she isn't healthy. Weight does not tell you body composition, so you can't tell everything from weight, but underweight is underweight.
Either way, your statement of "girls taht are physically active and eat very healthy look like that" --just isn't true. The majority of healthy female athletes do not look like that. Here are a couple of examples....or do these Olympic athletes look fat to you?
So stop pulling out the strawman-- just because someone says that girl is too skinny does not mean they're an advocate for fast food and obesity.
^excuse typos, I didn't proof read it.
holy fucking time waste.
come on man, no one was arguing that being overweight is healthy. Both being overweight and being underweight are unhealthy. The argument was whether or not that specific girl was underweight and whether or not her size was attractive.
You started off by saying she looked good and that she was an example of all physically active and nutritionally conscious women. Then you flip flopped. Everything else you had to say was either not relevant to my standpoint, something I don't care to argue, or an attempt to inform me about something I already know.
Since you agreed that she is too thin, I don't really see the point in continuing. What are we arguing at this point? Whether or not being underweight is less healthy than being overweight? I'd rather not- they're both unhealthy and I'll just leave it at that.
found out her name. here are some more pics..her name is sasha markina and she is a russian model-- no i didnt stalk her, these are from google images. Didn't really want to continue an argument, just thought I'd share since these are more revealing. Granted some photos on google images she appears a little heavier, not sure if those are older or more recent.
[IMG]lionsdenu.com/wp-content/uploads/2012/11/43xcsE1UKvE.jpg[/IMG]