Welcome to the Newschoolers forums! You may read the forums as a guest, however you must be a registered member to post. Register to become a member today!
This doesn't make any sense. Food has a set energy component - either you're eating 1200 calories or you're not. You can't "have a 1200 calorie diet but only eat 500 calories".
Personally I lost a shitload of weight a few years ago, and then spent the last year and a half putting weight back on the "right way". To compare the two, it's WAY easier to lose weight just doing cardio and a strict high protein low carb cal deficit diet (i.e. a weight loss diet) than it is to follow that up by eating well and consistently and getting the right workout regimen week after week to build muscle.
What you should be doing is something like Mike-O. Different people can stick with different regimes, and it's more important to have something you can realistically do on an ongoing basis than it is to optimize everything. I did mostly elliptical and rowing with light weight high rep, or even body weight stuff, about 75-25 cardio to weights. You end up skinny (but not strong) leaning down that way.
If I were to do it again I would do a wider range of cardio, my current cardio workout is only once a week when not doing weights - but it's recumbent bike 10mins, 55 flights of stairs, 2km row, 10mins elliptical, straight bike 10mins. Follow that up with 10 mins of core (I do 25 crunch / rest, 25 leg lift / rest, 25 extension / rest, 25 reverse crunch rest) and call it a day. If you keep your heart rate above 130 (which is super easy to do) it's a really solid workout and you don't end up labouring for 30 mins on one machine which is a pain.
right on
for all you fatties, don't eat refined carbs and you will win