Welcome to the Newschoolers forums! You may read the forums as a guest, however you must be a registered member to post. Register to become a member today!
To throw something constructive out there, even though I'm not entirely certain about this thread...
Cactus SPG all-leather glove + Icebreaker merino wool liner. Insanely waterproof and windproof, really warm, damn near bulletproof outer (although the Icebreakers fall apart pretty quickly). Cheap considering what you get. Goretex cuff. Good dexterity for a full-size (not spring style) glove. Merino wool liner means they don't get stinky. And you can re-proof them with some good boot wax.
A lot of the Antarctic research staff wear the SPG. To me, that's a pretty good endorsement.