The Punx and Recoil are two very different skis. The Punx is a symmetrical all-park ski while the Recoil is a rockered, non-symmetrical and rather stiff all-mountain ski.
I think that you should consider your skiing style. The Recoil is going to be a lot more versatile but the fully symmetrical sidecut of the Punx might make more sense if you're going to spend all of your time in the park.