Welcome to the Newschoolers forums! You may read the forums as a guest, however you must be a registered member to post. Register to become a member today!
this thread is one big claimfest.
well were at it, i was on the cover of musclemag lastweek. so FUUU
I can’t really tell if you’re being sarcastic. I have one semester left in my degree and I have found it extremely difficult in some aspects, others not as much. And if you’re trying to imply that my program is full of jocks and meat heads, that is not the case. I’ll admit exercise physiology is one of the courses I did find challenging, and it is by no means my calling.
But lets just clarify, are you wanting to use it as part of your training for skiing or for skiing itself?
Now this is why I think you would be wasting your time and money using creatine for skiing. I’m sure you are aware that creatine is generally used as a supplement by power athletes such as weightlifters to enhance stores of high-energy compound creatine phosphate in the muscles, in theory the more creatine phosphate in your body the more you can train right? And yes, some studies suggest that creatine supplementation may enhance high-intensity strength training, but other studies have found no increase in strength with creatine supplementation, so its pretty controversial that if it does anything at all in terms of actual performance (not just increase mass). I think there was a study with an obstacle course and navy seals and they showed no benefits in performance with creatine supplements when compared to a placebo. And it’s a bit a safety concern too, no long term studies have been conducted on the safety of creatine supplementation.
I know creatine phosphate has an essential role in energy metabolism in the formation of ATP by rephosphoeylating ADP. But what I’m saying is the way in which most of us ski we would more use the glycolotic system not the, ATP-PC system, my logic for this is just the duration. Like if you were say an Olympic mogul skier, yes, I think there would be potential benefits to creatine supplements cause you do what a 30 second run, bam, you’re done. But the majority of park/ big mountain skiers will go for like 3+ hours of skiing, yes, it’s a low intensity so maybe you can have some on reserve. But I never really find when I’m skiing park that there is a time where I used 100% of my physical strength to produce force. Like I get what you mean when you say power out on a backseat landing, but I’m not sure that really is applicable because its more testing an eccentric and isometric muscles stability or the integrity of your ACL. And also, using creatine wouldn’t really improve your maximum power output would it? More just how long you could sustain it, 20% is it? And like I’ve had a few runs where I’ve gone hard, but I don’t think I’ve ever skied or been in a position to have be in 100% effort for more than 5 seconds. Get what I mean?
And if you’re doing any hiking or work to get around the mountain I think you would move onto another energy system than the ATP-PC as its really only for 5-15 seconds. And I guess if were just hucking one cliff you might use the ATP-PC system, but like it would be really hard to control that because most of these locations require quite a bit of energy to get to. And marathon runners can train their body to reserve their ATP-PC system till the end of their race, but that would require more training of the oxidative system, which might not be that useful to skiing.
I was kinda on the same boat as you this summer, I tried to make the majority of my training target the ATP-PC system. But what I found water ramping this summer despite only being for short durations, I tired too quickly to get the volume in to make me a better skier. I found that I was better off developing my other systems. But I guess that’s where you were going with by having a supplement but there is a saturation limit. And I think we would tap out with our type of skiing and I’d just rather focus on other ways that I think would improve my skiing more. Agree or disagree, that’s just how I see it, I’ve never used the supplements nor have met anyone who used them for skiing so I guess its not fair for me to judge. I’d be interested to hear how you found it this season.