Replying to Disorderly Vs. Anthem. I hate threads like this

Ok, I know, searchbar.  But I am in a bind and can't decide. 

History: 

I bought surface watch life's in January and they delamed this weekend.  Surface will not warrenty them and backcountry.com will only give me the price that I paid for the skis, which won't cover any other skis from backcountry.com.  So I have limited funds.

Good news: 

I can get anthems and disorderlys for the same price (within my refund price).  but I can't decide.  I like the disorderlys becasue of the cap construction, rivets, k2 standard badassness, and all my k2s have held up really well. 

I like the anthems because I like a wider park ski, I have skid them before and I liked them, but I am skeptical on their durability.  I am graduating college this year and need something to get me through the economic slowdown. 

Please halp!