Member of the Month

hi_vis360
November, 2024

Online

Welcome to the Newschoolers forums! You may read the forums as a guest, however you must be a registered member to post. Register to become a member today!

Organ Donor

profile picture
crzyskier311xxx
Posts: 515 - Karma: 12

A case of a snowboarder being taken off life support came up today over getting his organs harvested.  Im wondering what everyone here feels about organ donation.  Do you feel that a doctor will actually hasten your death if you put yourself as an organ donor?  Also, state why you think they will or wont.

Mar 16 2009 12:40PM
0 0
profile picture
kepler.
Posts: 8761 - Karma: 139
Mar 16 2009 12:43PM
0 0
profile picture
8ONE657
Posts: 3045 - Karma: 209
thats such a touchy subject. i mean don't get me wrong if i was no longer capable of living and someone else could survive from my parts i'd be all for that but i chose not to be an organ donor because i wouldn't want to die prematurely if i had a chance to live. i don't give blood which i know isn't reall friendly but it's cause i don't wanna be harassed by the blood banks and also cause i'm deathly afraid of needles.
Mar 16 2009 1:32PM
0 0
profile picture
GhostfaceKillah
Posts: 3398 - Karma: 10
i hate thread hijackers..... they are ruining NS.

I see no issue with donating organs, i'm pretty sure it says i'm an organ donor on my divers licesne. I also donate blood whenever I can. If i get crushed by an 18-wheeler in an accident and have to live on life support like a vegitable, i would rather my healthy organs go to someone who could actually use them, rather than have them go to waste inside myself.
Mar 16 2009 1:32PM
0 0
profile picture
davyjones
Posts: 617 - Karma: 12
when i worked for the funeral home on occasion an organ donor would come in...its pretty gross what they look like when they are done.
Mar 16 2009 1:38PM
0 0
profile picture
InNeon
Posts: 119 - Karma: 14
same opinion
Mar 16 2009 2:07PM
0 0
profile picture
freestyler540
Posts: 13110 - Karma: 18,939
I would donate my organs in case of death...Im dead so I wouldnt need them
Mar 16 2009 2:15PM
0 0
profile picture
Barefootin_Fiend
Posts: 7618 - Karma: 4,727
I donate my organ to my girlfriend on a pretty regular basis...
Mar 16 2009 2:16PM
0 0
profile picture
hartig
Posts: 8192 - Karma: 10
i'm an organ donor
Mar 16 2009 2:17PM
0 0
profile picture
Malcolm
Posts: 15951 - Karma: 9,451
haha clever.

id only donate organs if i was already dead.
Mar 16 2009 2:22PM
0 0
profile picture
crzyskier311xxx
Posts: 515 - Karma: 12

good stuff so far good opinions.  What do you guys think about doctors letting you die in order to harvest your organs cuz your a donor?  Think its true??  I don't, cuz in my mind if they would do that if your a donor then they could do the same the opposite way.  say your not a donor and need an organ, maybe they dont wanna give one to you...

Mar 16 2009 3:02PM
0 0
profile picture
Malcolm
Posts: 15951 - Karma: 9,451
maybe its like if you have a 50 % chance of survivng and some other guy who needs your organs has a 90 % chance of survivng if they get an organ transplant than they would do it.
Mar 16 2009 3:08PM
0 0
profile picture
user098123
Posts: 6072 - Karma: 18
bump

Watching House and the thought of Organ Donors came to me.  I am an organ donor and I'm proud of it.  On top of that, I don't see why almost everyone isn't an organ donor (barring religious beliefs).

In the case you describe, I can't imagine that doctors would just prematurely end your life.  Especially because it is the families decision to pull the plug, a doctor won't euthanize you.  In addition to this, what does the doctor have to gain?  I mean, they don't know how much your life is worth.  Also, they don't know how much the persons lie is worth on the top of the donor list.  Why take a life to give a life, when there might be an opportunity to save both lives down the road?


So I pose the question, should everyone automatically be an organ donor, and it is something that you opt out of?  This would provide many more organs for those in need and would alleviate many of the problems that the donor list  currently sees.
Nov 30 2009 11:53PM
0 0
profile picture
user098123
Posts: 6072 - Karma: 18
Call it selfish or I dunno what, but once you are dead why does it matter?  Ok, sure some of your body is harvested, but for the most part you look fine.

How about this, leave the eyes, skin and tissue (exterior parts) in place, and those are opt in.  For the rest of the internal organs, it is opt out, providing no preexisting health conditions.

Think of how many lives could be saved, and how can your body that you no longer use be put to a better purpose than to save the life of someone that can use it?
Dec 1 2009 12:14AM
0 0
profile picture
fosnow333
Posts: 120 - Karma: 13
haha. i dnt rly know if this is gross or funny. im leaning towards funny......lol
Dec 1 2009 12:31AM
0 0
profile picture
crzyskier311xxx
Posts: 515 - Karma: 12
In regards to the body, I am pretty sure I have heard somehwere that if organs are harvested after death they remove them in a very clean matter....not just hack you up.  So if you have an open casket funeral nobody can even tell.
Dec 4 2009 3:05PM
0 0
profile picture
Tasche
Posts: 5422 - Karma: 99
Do whatever the fuck you want with me. If a part of me can keep living in some one else I am all for it. Then burn the rest at a minimum of cost and get drunk, celebrate my life. Sell all my shit and give all the money to the Ronald McDonald foundation... (Burn my hard drive and I phone with me and clear my internet search history.)

There, my will is in writing, is anyone a notary?
Dec 4 2009 3:12PM
0 0
profile picture
Steezy_me123
Posts: 164 - Karma: 48
If I got someone good's organs would make me better?
Dec 4 2009 3:34PM
0 0
profile picture
Slinger1x1
Posts: 8853 - Karma: 66
it's just like a women. Even after you're dead, they still wanna tear your heart out!!!
Dec 4 2009 4:10PM
0 0
profile picture
LMPJibbin
Posts: 1607 - Karma: 17
ya i agree theres no point in being a veggie
Dec 4 2009 4:25PM
0 0
profile picture
deleted5
Posts: 14507 - Karma: 13,507
when you donate only something like 4% of people that die can donate there organs. you need to be brain dead but you blood still running or something like that. you will have a 0 chance of coming back to live when they take the stuff out.
Dec 4 2009 4:25PM
0 0
profile picture
MAPLE_SYRUP
Posts: 1910 - Karma: 68
i don't donate blood because i hate needles but i am an organ donor
Dec 4 2009 4:28PM
0 0
profile picture
Arabian.
Posts: 9648 - Karma: 236
Ya'll ain't gettin' mah orginz.
Dec 4 2009 4:28PM
0 0
profile picture
soulskier
Posts: 17806 - Karma: 3,841
i guess i never really thought of a doctor quickening my death to save someone elses like that
but if my death inevitabe, why delay?
Dec 4 2009 4:29PM
0 0
profile picture
pmills
Posts: 7162 - Karma: 59
I wouldn't mind having organ donation as the standard and making it an option to opt out.
Dec 4 2009 4:42PM
0 0
profile picture
OhMyBosh
Posts: 5056 - Karma: 171
anyone who isnt an organ donor is a selfish cunt.
Dec 4 2009 5:27PM
0 0
profile picture
noparking
Posts: 1123 - Karma: 50
Just go all you guys know if you put organ donor on your license or tell you family that in the sudden case of you death I would like my organs donated that doesn't mean shit and legally they Will Not harvest your organs. You must have a legal document that it signed by you ahead of time.
Dec 4 2009 5:35PM
0 0
profile picture
skiminnesota
Posts: 9093 - Karma: 429
Organ donor right here.

If im dead, i sure as hell dont need them, give them to someone who has a chance of living.
Dec 4 2009 5:42PM
0 0
profile picture
Arabian.
Posts: 9648 - Karma: 236
Wrong mr. spacey too high.

People who expect people to give up body parts because they were too retarded (except the kids with diseases) are the selfish ones.
Dec 4 2009 5:44PM
0 0
profile picture
Tasche
Posts: 5422 - Karma: 99
I like the attempt at trolling but I hope no one will bite.
Dec 4 2009 5:45PM
0 0
profile picture
frosted_flakes
Posts: 1200 - Karma: 1,256
Click for larger image

organs are expensive
Dec 4 2009 5:53PM
0 0
profile picture
OhMyBosh
Posts: 5056 - Karma: 171
youre dead. your body no longer belongs to you, it no longer has your rights.

Dec 4 2009 7:34PM
0 0
profile picture
Arabian.
Posts: 9648 - Karma: 236
I disagree. That logic would mean that all rights to earthly possessions also die with you. How come people don't just steal all yo sheet when you die then?
Dec 4 2009 8:07PM
0 0
profile picture
OhMyBosh
Posts: 5056 - Karma: 171
they do... unless you write in a will that you give them to your family... then they are in their possession and no longer yours.
Dec 4 2009 8:22PM
0 0
profile picture
Arabian.
Posts: 9648 - Karma: 236
Well then thank you for disrespecting my will. How come you don't get all uppity about other people not sharing their shit once they die? Your a BODY COMMUNIST, MAN!!!!! You don't deserve that shit.
Dec 4 2009 8:24PM
0 0
profile picture
Slinger1x1
Posts: 8853 - Karma: 66
well, no, thats not true
if you die and have organ donor on your license, they can harvest your organs but i think your family has the right to stop it.
so if your a nobody, with no family, but you have organ donor on your license, then they can harvest your organs.
Dec 4 2009 8:50PM
0 0
profile picture
OhMyBosh
Posts: 5056 - Karma: 171
youre fucking dead. nobody needs them, youre no longer using them, and nobody else owns them. so why let them rot underground when you could be saving someones life?
Dec 4 2009 8:52PM
0 0
profile picture
onearmwanderer
Posts: 1153 - Karma: 31
nope that is not true, at least in my state.  they go through your family first, if your an organ donor and they ask your family and they say no, they cant take your organs.  i dont know about the "nobody" case but they are usually pretty careful about it i'd assume.  people would get really pissed off if they didnt want their relatives organs taken and they werent asked first i'd bet.
Dec 4 2009 8:54PM
0 0
profile picture
Slinger1x1
Posts: 8853 - Karma: 66
you just restated what i said...
your family does have the last word...
Dec 4 2009 8:57PM
0 0
profile picture
Arabian.
Posts: 9648 - Karma: 236
Why not just take the land that no one's using? Why not steal some dead guy's car?

And you still haven't answered the biggest question:

Why do you DESERVE my organs? If some douchebag needs a liver transplant because he drank too much, or someone smoked too much and needs my lungs, or someone punctured a kidney because she was texting LOL LIKE OMG while driving, I don't think it should go to them.

There's no small dotted line that says my organs will go to someone who actually needs them (25 and under, diseased).

And I don't want to give doctors incentive to deny me care. I'd rather see 3 Tiny Tims die than support the drinking habits of 10 chads.
Dec 4 2009 9:36PM
0 0
profile picture
Slinger1x1
Posts: 8853 - Karma: 66
its not either going to a sick kid or a old drunk...
people have random heart problems, kidney problems, liver problems all the time.

My english teacher got throat cancer a couple years ago (it was cured though). he never smoked or anything, he was an older man (50-60?) in good shape.

shit happens to people, why not help them out?

and why not be a good person and donate them anyway? so it goes to someone who was a drunk and now they can beat your liver to shit, your still a good person, and you don't need it. you still did a good deed. its like donating money to a bum. he might go out and buy booze, but you still did something good.

and what if you got sick and needed a liver? what if everyone had that same mentality that their organs will end up going to some low life? you would be pretty pissed

i also believe that drunks and smokers and people who inflict damage on their own body get knocked down on the donor list. i remember watching some doctor show (i mean its tv, but i doubt that they idea is fake...) and some guy who needed a liver drank some champaign at his daughters wedding and they wouldnt give him a liver.
Dec 4 2009 9:48PM
0 0
profile picture
OhMyBosh
Posts: 5056 - Karma: 171
you seem to assume the only people who need organ transplants are ones who are massive douchebags. i highly doubt there is any real backing to that claim, so ill just ignore it.

when you die, you lost all your rights. therefore, you really have no fucking reason to not give away your organs, and you will lose nothing and you could save someone (who isnt a douchebag's) life.
you're just being a fucking prick for no reason if you dont donate your organs.
Dec 4 2009 9:52PM
0 0
profile picture
Arabian.
Posts: 9648 - Karma: 236
THROAT CANCER CANNOT BE CURED WITH A TRANSPLANT.


I'm not donating my heart to some fat fuck who couldn't keep his shit in check. I'm not donating my tendons so some obese fuck can walk again cuz he wore out his own. I'm not giving my liver away or kidney away to someone who abuses themselves or doesn't take care of themeselves.

That's what it comes down to, but 90% of these people are just that, so fuck 'em. If Timmy wants my damn kidney, he can have it, but I'll be damned if the doctors steal my shit and give it to someone who doesn't deserve it.
Dec 4 2009 9:53PM
0 0
profile picture
OhMyBosh
Posts: 5056 - Karma: 171
once again, theyre not stealing your shit because its not yours when you're dead.
Dec 4 2009 10:32PM
0 0
profile picture
Crock360
Posts: 2100 - Karma: 23
Here's a better question:

If it's perfectly ok to donate an organ, whether posthumously or not, then WHY is it illegal to sell it?

If it's mine, and only I can give permission for someone else to have it, then why can't I try to sell it? It's mine.

It brings up the question George Carlin proposed about prostitution: Why is it illegal to sell something thats perfectly legal to give away?


I have mixed feelings about organ donations, but because I'm a cynical fuck sometimes. I am a donor, and I haven't heard a good reason for ANYONE to not be an organ donor, but at the same time if everyone was then not as many people would die, and there are too many people in the world as it is...
Dec 4 2009 10:33PM
0 0
profile picture
OhMyBosh
Posts: 5056 - Karma: 171
i imagine its illegal to sell organs because then youll have people going around killing people and harvesting their organs for money...
also you'd have to have a legit knowledge of where the organ came from and that persons medical history etc. etc.


as for prostitution, it shouldnt be illegal.

organ donation is different than prostitution in that youre not giving away your organs, youre dead, and no longer own them, therefore they can be taken from you.
Dec 4 2009 10:42PM
0 0
profile picture
Arabian.
Posts: 9648 - Karma: 236
I don't get your logic. Possession is everything material but the human body right? There's a lot of incongruity in your argument.


Dec 4 2009 10:53PM
0 0
profile picture
OhMyBosh
Posts: 5056 - Karma: 171
you own your body when you are alive, you dont when your dead.
you shouldnt give a shit what happens to your organs when you die because you no longer exist, nor should you go so far as to (use even go want to do look more like?) say that certain people dont deserve your organs because of shit you can only speculate about.
Dec 4 2009 11:01PM
0 0
profile picture
Arabian.
Posts: 9648 - Karma: 236
That remains to be seen, and is highly contested whether or not we stop existing, which is also shit we can only speculate about and use even go want to do look more like.

I think that my body is mine from birth, and it should stay that way. That's why you can't dismember corpses or dig up graves, or commit necrophilia.
Dec 4 2009 11:09PM
0 0
profile picture
M+M
Posts: 7935 - Karma: 25
except for that recent news about the veggie for 20 years who just woke up and told us he knew everything going on around him the whole time even though he couldnt communicate it
Dec 4 2009 11:10PM
0 0
profile picture
Lt-Aldo-Raine
Posts: 2309 - Karma: 120
This is the case most of the time. People wait months for other people to die in order to recive thier organs.
Dec 4 2009 11:25PM
0 0
All times are Eastern (-5)