dont get baggy holdens, it just looks silly, xl is when they get baggy. and it just looks wierd and gapery. if you want super tight, get smalls, but i wouldnt reccomend that, just cause smalls would be a pain, ive never tried on mediums, but i have tried on larges, which fit my 32in waist perfect when you tighten down the velcro thingys, you can sag them, and they have that tight look but with a good amount of extra baggage, i think its cause they still fit tight, but are longer so the material builds up, xl's get fat and just look silly. mediums i think would work well too if you dont want much extra material, they would probably fit a 32 inch waist perfect, but it would be hard to get any bagginess if you wanted some.
and im 5'9, 150ish.
how tall are you and how much you weigh? thats what matters most.