after lots of searching I finally decided to get an Epiphone Les Paul:
This this is sick as hell, sounds just like a lot of the Gibsons I played. Has great dynamic range, super rich groovy tone. I absolutely love it. only $435 too.
PRS guitars are fucking amazing, one day I will have a doublecut semi-hollowbody...but they are $2,000+
My advice: go to the store, try as many as you can, find what feels good. Test it out with an amp that is similar to yours, and do tests. Check for intonation, feedback, sustain, etc.
If you do enough research, you could find a really good guitar for around $500, then spend the rest on effects shit. I recommend reverb, chorus, overdrive, delay, etc.
Right now I have a Boss DD-7 delay with an overdrive pedal, and I'm about to pick up a phat reverb pedal so I can play cello bow on my guitar.