Let`s even assume that once they take all of these profits away, the price of oil and gas will magically, and against all known rules of economics, begin to decrease. What happens then?
Cheaper gas means more people buying it and less incentive to find real long-term solutions, all of which means we just rely on foreign oil more than ever before. And that`s not hope and that`s not a change. That`s typical Washington politics. You solve a problem by creating an even bigger one.
Brian Carney is the editorial writer of "The Wall Street Journal" editorial board.
Brian, taking away the windfall profits and having a windfall profits tax on oil, didn`t we try this in the `80s?
BRIAN CARNEY, "THE WALL STREET JOURNAL": We did try this in the `80s. And what happened is exactly what you would expect, Glenn. Domestic production and exploration went down. Imports went up. And prices did not go down either.
BECK: Oh boy.
CARNEY: And we can expect more of the same if we try it again.
BECK: Brian, how much are you taking from big oil? You`re clearly in bed with them. I mean, that`s what they`ll say.
CARNEY: I take nothing. No, it`s true. But we can look back at the experience of the `80s.
We actually tried this. And exactly what you would expect would happen happened. You tax something, you get less of it. And the countries that are taxing it less will import more of it to us.
So, those who are concerned about, you know, importing foreign oil or OPEC`s influence over us, a windfall profits tax is the last thing they should be arguing for.
BECK: OK. Here is the thing. Everybody trying to make these guys as robber barons. They`re not robber barons.
I saw -- the Cato Institute said that their profits are in line with the rest of American industry. The robber barons, the ones that are destroying us and robbing us blind, are these politicians.
CARNEY: That`s right. Their return on investment is only marginally higher right now than it is for American industry as a whole.
BECK: I have the stats if you don`t -- 7.8 is the average for the all American industry. They`re at 8.3. Oh, my gosh, they`re just worthless pigs just robbing us blind.
CARNEY: They also pay a lot of taxes already. Exxon paid $9.3 billion in corporate income taxes on those profits that they made in the first quarter. And they paid even more than that when you take into account the royalties and other taxes that they paid -- $29.3 billion in total taxes paid in the first three months of this year.
And they want to say that there ought to be a higher tax? I mean...
BECK: Yes, they`re already paying 35 percent tax.
____________________________
(____________________________)
FOOT NOTES!
------
They also pay a lot of taxes already. Exxon paid $9.3 billion in corporate income taxes on those profits that they made in the first quarter. And they paid even more than that when you take into account the royalties and other taxes that they paid -- $29.3 billion in total taxes paid in the first three months of this year.
------
I saw -- the Cato Institute said that their profits are in line with the rest of American industry. The robber barons, the ones that are destroying us and robbing us blind, are these politicians.
CARNEY: That`s right. Their (Oil Companies) return on investment is only marginally higher right now than it is for American industry as a whole.
BECK: I have the stats if you don`t -- 7.8 is the average for the all American industry. They`re at 8.3. Oh, my gosh, they`re just worthless pigs just robbing us blind.
------
http://transcripts.cnn.com/TRANSCRIPTS/0805/05/gb.01.html