Replying to K2 Poacher or Dynastar Menace 98

I'm new to the forum, but I did some research before signing up. I'm looking for a replacement for 184cm shreditor 92s. I want something that's just as damp and fast through crud, and just as soft and buttery also, but wider. The obvious choice would be a 184cm poacher, but my research on this site from some helpful threads also led me towards the 187cm Dynastar Menace 98. I think the actual lengths should be similar, but the Dynastar is heavier along with having a longer turn radius, leading me to believe it should be better in soft or firm crud, and all mountain.

I don't want to go as long as the 192 Black Ops for a freestyle ski. I tried 188 PB&J and they were very fun, but I want something softer, but heavier and more damp.

Thank you for any recommendations.