see this isnt fair
they're comparing a somewhat heavy woman to an OVERLY skinny woman
first girl is equal to first guy
second girl is not equal to second guy
put a girl like Bar Rafaeli as the second girl and THEN you have a correct comparison.
brad pitt is like the epitome of what girls look for in guys, six pack, jacked, good looks (no homo), but the second girl is NOT what guys look for in a girl...